To primitive man, a comet was something to be feared, a portent of an impending disaster. Because comets brighten relatively rapidly when they get close to the sun, and because bright comets (visible to the naked eye) are relatively rare, comets would appear in the sky suddenly and unexpectedly. In addition, near perihelion, comet tails can extend millions of kilometers in space (making them the largest objects in the solar system), thus depending on the geometry of the orbit, the tail can have a length projected against the sky which is a large fraction of the celestial sphere. In an era where the celestial realm was the realm of the gods, the sudden appearance of an unknown object which dominated the night sky was terrifying.
In the Greek Era, the nature of the comets was intensely debated, but the theme of fear was prevalent as seen in this cometary quote from the greatest Greek author of antiquity, Homer:
"[The helmut of Achilles shone] like the red star, that from his flaming hair shakes down disease, pestilence, and war" (Iliad, Bk. XIX, 11, 380-3).
This figure shows the Great Comet of 1843 as seen from Kent, England (Chambers, 1909). Because these comets appear suddenly and are seen by a multitude of people, nobody can be claimed as the discoverer. One of the most spectacular historical comets was the Great Comet of 1811 (Flaugergues) which was observed for an unprecedented 17 months. When discovered, it was 5th magnitude and over 2 AU from the sun. The maximum tail length was estimated to be 100 million miles. This comet attracted the attention of Napoleon as presaging his invasion of Russia, yet others wondered "what misfortune does it bring?" (Chambers, 1909).
|Year||Comet name (if known)||Additional Comments|
|1066||Halley||Portent of Wm the Conqueror|
|1106||-||Widely visible in day - Europe & Orient|
|1145||Halley||Well documented by Chinese|
|1402||-||Comet visible in broad daylight|
|1456||Halley||Comet was excommunicated by the Pope!|
|1577||-||Observed by Tycho Brahe; tail 80 deg long|
|1618||-||Tail 104 degrees|
|1661||-||6 degree tail & multiple nucleus structures|
|1680||Kirch||Max tail arc of 90 deg.|
|1682||Halley||Epoch of E. Halley's observations|
|1689||-||Discovered at sea, tail 68 deg|
|1729||Sarabat||Large perihelion distance|
|1744||De Cheseaux||Remarkable appearance with 6 tails|
|1759||Great Comet||Passed 0.07 AU from Earth|
|1769||Messier||Tail length exceeded 90 degrees|
|1811||Flaugergues||Unprecedented 17 mo. visibility|
|1823||Great Comet||Large sunward anti-tail|
|1843||Great Comet||Sungrazing comet|
|1858||Donati||Most beautiful comet on record|
|1861||Tebbutt||Daytime "auroral glow" reported|
|1874||Coggia||Unusual jet features|
|1880||Great S. Comet||Orbit resembles comet of 1843|
|1881||Great Comet||Only comet spectrum observed before 1907|
|1882||Great Comet||Orbit resembles comet of 1880|
|1887||Great S. Comet||Orbit resembles comet of 1843|
|1901||Great S. Comet||Brightness rivaled that of Sirius|
Comets were objects of much speculation among the early Greek astronomers, some of whom considered them to be planetary in nature, and others, such as Aristotle, considered them to be more of an atmospheric phenomena, such as meteors. The first real scientific facts known about comets were due to the observations of the great observer Tycho Brahe (1546-1601). Brahe made measurements of the position of the Great Comet of 1577 and determined from its parallax that it was a distant object, much farther away than the Moon, and therefore not an atmospheric phenomenon as many had believed. It was Edmond Halley (1656-1742) along with his contemporary Sir Isaac Newton (1643-1727) who contributed to the first physical understanding of the nature of comets. Halley's first experience with comets was with the spectacular appearance of the comet of 1680, and of the comet of 1682 (which was later to bear his name) and he became very interested in understanding how they moved. After observing these bright comets, Halley began contemplating the theory of gravitation with others at the Royal Society, but they needed a mathematical basis for their discussions. Halley approached his friend, Isaac Newton, the only man capable of working out the proof - and was surprised to learn that Newton had solved the problem many years earlier, but had lost his notes. At Halley's urging, Newton was convinced to re-work his calcuations, and Halley paid for their publication in the Principia. Using this, Halley was able to calculate comet orbits, and he noticed that the orbits of the comets of 1531, 1607 and 1682 looked very similar. He proposed that they were the same comet returning every 76 years, and that the comet would return in 1759. Although he died before the prediction could be verified, the comet was recovered on January 21, 1758, and it was named in honor of him (usually comets are named after their discoverers).
Both intense public interest in observing comets and fear over their apparitions has continued from the time of Halley and Newton. In the figure at the left the celebration of the discovery of a bright comet at Greenwich Observatory was published in Punch in 1906 (Chambers, 1909). At the same time people still feared comets as evidenced from the advertisements of comet pills to fend off the evils effects of the passage through comet Halley's tail in 1910, and the concern over the appearance of Biela's comet in 1872: "The fear which took possession of many citizens has not yet abated. The general expectation herabouts was that the comet would be heard from on Saturday night. As one result, the confessionals of the two Catholic churches here were crowded yesterday evening. As the night advanced there were many who insisted that they could detect a change in the atmosphere. The air, they said, was stifling..." (Chambers, 1909).
[ About PSRD |
[ Glossary | General Resources | Comments | Top of page ]